Reputation must be built before a crisis because during a crisis people judge a company by what it has already shown them, and there is no time to build trust from scratch. Johnson & Johnson's 1982 Tylenol recall shows the effect: a written Credo gave its chief executive a decision order that let the company act within days at a cost of about $100 million.
By Ronn Torossian. Last updated: November 19, 2026. Cases and quotes are attributed to named sources. The five-part build list is editorial judgment, and the example documents are hypothetical templates for a fictional company.
What did the Credo do for Johnson & Johnson?
The Credo gave Johnson & Johnson a decision order before the crisis began. Seven people near Chicago died after taking cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules in late September 1982, and Johnson & Johnson recalled about 31 million bottles at an estimated cost of $100 million, according to Wharton Knowledge. The Credo, a one-page statement, says the company is responsible first to its customers, then to its employees, the community and the stockholders, in that order, according to the same Wharton report.
James Burke, Johnson & Johnson chief executive from 1976 to 1989, said the Credo "gave me the ammunition I needed to persuade shareholders" and others to spend the $100 million on the recall, as quoted by Wharton. The company had decided whom it served first long before it had to make an urgent choice.
Why does trust disappear faster than it is built?
Trust disappears faster than it is built because one visible failure can outweigh years of quiet success. Warren Buffett told an interviewer that Berkshire Hathaway had been named one of the most admired companies in the world, which took 37 years, and said it could be lost "in 37 minutes," as reported by Benzinga in January 2025.
Reputation functions as an earned reserve rather than an abstract asset. A company with a deep reserve receives the benefit of the doubt while gathering facts, whereas a company without one does not. The guide to great communicators includes Warren Buffett's 1991 testimony on the same theme.
What should a company build before a crisis?
A company should build five specific assets before an incident occurs: an explicit priority order, a public track record of plain statements, direct communication channels, relationships with working reporters, and an operational plan. Each initiative can be established this quarter.
| Asset | Purpose |
|---|---|
| 1. A written priority order | Lets leaders decide quickly, as the Credo did |
| 2. A track record of plain statements | Gives the public a reason to believe the first response |
| 3. Owned channels | A website page and mailing list that reach audiences directly |
| 4. Reporter relationships | Journalists who know how you work before an incident occurs |
| 5. A tested crisis plan | Designated owners, decision clocks, and pre-approved templates rehearsed annually |
How do you write a priority order?
You write a priority order as a short statement that ranks the groups the company serves and says what each is owed. The Johnson & Johnson Credo ranks customers first and stockholders last, according to Wharton Knowledge. The example below is a hypothetical for a fictional company, Northwind Foods, and is not the Johnson & Johnson text.
"Northwind Foods serves, in this order: the people who eat our food, the people who make and deliver it, the retailers and restaurants who sell it, and the people who own the company. When a decision pits one group against another, we choose in that order and we explain why." The chief executive signs it, and leaders test it against two or three past decisions to confirm it would have produced the same answers.
How do you build a track record of plain statements?
You build it by publishing short, factual updates on routine matters, so the public has seen how the company writes before a crisis. Plain statements on a delayed product, a price change or a corrected error show that the company reports bad news as well as good.
A company that has a record of admitting small mistakes is easier to believe about a large one. The list below shows three practices that create the record, and the list is editorial judgment.
- Publish a dated correction page for errors in public materials.
- Explain price or policy changes in one paragraph, with the reason.
- Report results against stated goals, including the ones missed.
How do you set up owned channels?
You set up owned channels by choosing the places where the company will post updates in a crisis and building audiences there in advance. A status or news page on the company's website and an email list for customers reach people without an intermediary.
Name the page, the owner and the update time in the crisis plan, and test a mock post every year. A channel with no readers on the day of a crisis does little, so use it for routine news throughout the year.
How do you build reporter relationships before a crisis?
You build them by being useful to reporters when nothing is wrong. Muck Rack's 2026 State of Journalism report, which surveyed 897 journalists from January 30 to March 2, 2026, found that 88 percent immediately delete pitches that miss their beat, as summarized by MediaPost. Relationships therefore start with relevance: sending data a reporter can use and answering questions quickly.
A reporter who has worked with a company on routine stories knows who to call and what the company's facts are worth. The media relations strategy guide covers how to build those relationships.
How does Page's fourth principle apply?
The fourth Page Principle, manage for tomorrow, tells organizations to anticipate public reaction and eliminate practices that create difficulties, according to the Arthur W. Page Society. Applied to crisis planning, the principle means documenting values, keeping verifiable records and building media relationships before an urgent issue arises.
The crisis communication plan template and the guide to the first 24 hours provide structures for response planning. In addition, the PR crisis examples page and the reputation management pillar examine historical organizational outcomes.
What does an annual readiness schedule look like?
An annual schedule spreads the five assets across the year, with one task per quarter. This schedule is editorial judgment and not a standard.
| Quarter | Task | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| First | Review and re-sign the priority order; update the crisis owner list | CEO and communications |
| Second | Refresh holding statement templates and test the owned channels | Communications |
| Third | Hold a one-hour drill using a made-up incident | Crisis team and counsel |
| Fourth | Review the year's statements for plainness and fix gaps | Communications and legal |
Frequently asked questions
Why build reputation before a crisis?
Reputation must be built before a crisis because external audiences evaluate an organization under stress based on its established baseline of trust. Trust cannot be created quickly during an unfolding emergency.
What did Johnson & Johnson do in the Tylenol crisis?
Johnson & Johnson recalled about 31 million Tylenol bottles at an estimated cost of $100 million in 1982. The recall adhered to the customer-first standard set by its Credo, according to Wharton Knowledge.
What is the first step to take?
The first step is to draft a single-page document stating whether customers, employees, or shareholders come first, second, and third, and secure the chief executive's signature. Completing this order shapes executive decisions on the organization's worst day.
Can a small company do this?
Yes. A priority order is one page, a correction page is one URL and a drill takes an hour, so a small company can complete all five assets in a quarter.
How do you know the reputation reserve is growing?
No source offers a single measure. Practical signs include reporters who call you first, customers who accept a plain explanation of a mistake and a record of corrections that you can point to.
Draft the one-page priority order this week, and ask your leadership team whether it would have changed a past decision.
