The CEO should set the goal and the CMO should run the selection, with the decision owner depending on what the PR is for. Reputation, crisis, investor and executive work belongs to the CEO. Brand, launch and demand work belongs to the CMO. A third person, usually the general counsel or head of communications, should test crisis readiness before anyone signs.
By Ronn Torossian. Last updated: November 7, 2026. I run a PR agency, so I see both CEOs and CMOs make this decision. The framework below is my own judgment, not survey data, and this guide cites no statistics.
Summary: This guide explains who should own the PR agency decision, assigns common PR goals to the CEO or the CMO, shows how the two executives and legal counsel can divide the work and lists the questions each should ask before signing.
Contents
Who should own the PR agency decision?
The decision owner should be the executive whose goal the PR serves, because that person lives with the result. When PR protects reputation, supports a transaction or prepares for a crisis, the CEO owns the outcome. When PR supports a launch, a brand campaign or demand, the CMO owns it.
Problems start when ownership is unclear. The CMO chooses an agency for brand work, and the CEO later expects the same firm to handle a crisis. Or the CEO picks a firm through a personal relationship and does not tell the CMO, who then inherits a scope no one planned.
Company size changes the details but not the principle. In a small company the CEO may play both roles. In a large company the decision may involve several more people. In both cases, one person should be named as the owner before the search begins.
Which PR goals belong to the CEO and which to the CMO?
Each common PR goal has a natural owner, and the table below assigns them. The assignments are my judgment, and a company can change them if its structure is different.
| PR goal | Decision owner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate reputation and executive visibility | CEO | The CEO is the subject and often the spokesperson |
| Crisis readiness and response | CEO with general counsel | Legal exposure and fast decisions sit with the CEO |
| Investor, funding and M&A communications | CEO with CFO | Statements can affect disclosure and valuation |
| Product launches and brand campaigns | CMO | The CMO owns the budget and the channels |
| Demand, lead generation and content | CMO | Results connect to the marketing plan |
| AI visibility and search presence | CMO with CEO input | Marketing owns the channels, and the CEO's name appears in answers |
Many companies need both kinds of work. In that case, write two scopes in the agreement, one for reputation and one for marketing, and name the owner of each. A single scope with two owners usually means nobody owns it.
What does each executive bring to the agency selection?
Each executive brings something the others lack, and a good selection uses all of it. The list shows what each person adds.
- The CEO brings access to spokespeople, a view of risk and the authority to say yes quickly.
- The CMO brings budget ownership, channel knowledge and experience measuring marketing results.
- The general counsel brings a view of legal exposure, especially for crisis and disclosure work.
- The CFO brings a check on retainers, out-of-pocket costs and contract terms.
An agency should meet at least the CEO and the CMO before signing. A firm that never meets the CEO cannot judge how much executive time the work will get, and a firm that never meets the CMO cannot judge how the work fits the marketing plan.
How should the CEO and CMO divide the work?
The CEO should set the goal, the CMO should run the process and counsel should test the crisis plan. The table shows who leads each step. These roles are a suggested split, not a standard.
| Step | CEO | CMO | Counsel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Set the goal | Decides | Consulted | Informed |
| Build the shortlist | Informed | Leads | Informed |
| Run the pitch meetings | Attends the final round | Leads | Attends for crisis scope |
| Test crisis readiness | Attends | Takes part | Leads |
| Negotiate contract and costs | Approves | Leads | Reviews |
| Sign off | Decides | Recommends | Reviews |
The crisis test deserves its own session. Ask each finalist to walk through its first-hour steps for a realistic incident, and compare the answers with a crisis communication plan template. The crisis communications case studies give examples of what good and poor first statements look like.
What goes wrong when the wrong person decides?
Three failures repeat when the wrong person decides, and each one is avoidable. All three come from my own observation of how these decisions go, not from a survey.
When the CMO decides alone, the agency often learns after signing that executive time is scarce. A reputation program needs the CEO to give interviews, approve quotes and sometimes answer hard questions. If the CEO was never part of the pitch, those hours may not exist.
When the CEO decides alone, the firm may be chosen on a personal relationship and not on fit. The CMO's team then inherits a scope, a budget and a reporting style they did not shape, and the work suffers from the start.
When price decides, the cheapest firm often wins by default. The guide to the hidden costs of the cheapest agency lists what a low quote can leave out, and the guide to PR firm costs for startups shows what usually sits outside a retainer.
What should each executive ask the PR agencies?
Each executive should ask the questions that match the risks they own, and the agencies should hear both sets. The questions below are my own list.
Questions a CEO should ask
- Who will speak for the company if a story breaks on a weekend?
- How much of my time does this program need each week?
- What would you tell me if a month went badly?
- How will you protect my name in search results and AI answers?
- Which of my peers have you advised on a similar problem, and can I speak to them?
Questions a CMO should ask
- Which named reporters will you pitch for this launch, and why them?
- What will the monthly report show, and can I see a sample?
- Who works on the account, and for how many hours a week?
- Which costs sit outside the retainer?
- How does this work fit the content and channels we already run?
The guide to choosing a PR firm explains how to judge the answers, and the executive communications guide and the reputation management guide cover the CEO's side of the work in more depth.
I founded 5W, so weigh my views accordingly. The 5WPR PR agency page describes its services if you want to compare it against the other firms on your list.
Frequently asked questions
Should the CEO meet the agency team before signing?
Yes, at least in the final round. A CEO who skips the meeting cannot judge whether the team understands the company or how much executive time the work needs.
Should procurement choose the PR agency?
Procurement should check contract terms and costs, not make the choice. PR results depend on judgment and fit, which a price comparison cannot measure.
Does company size change who should decide?
Size changes the number of people involved but not the principle. In a small company one executive may play both roles. In a large company, name one owner and list who is consulted.
What if the CEO and the CMO disagree?
The owner of the goal should decide, and the other executive should record concerns in writing. For crisis and reputation work the CEO should decide. For launch and brand work the CMO should.
Before you invite the first agency, write one sentence that names the goal and the person who owns it. Send it to the CEO, the CMO and counsel, and ask each to confirm it.
