How do you choose a crisis PR firm? Ask eight questions: whether the firm has handled your type of crisis, which senior people will answer the phone, how fast it can start, how it works with your lawyers, what conflicts it holds, how it is paid, what references it offers, and how it measures results. Ask them before an incident, because a firm chosen mid-crisis is chosen under pressure.
Timing is the reason to decide early. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission requires public companies to file a Form 8-K generally within four business days after determining that a cybersecurity incident is material, per its July 26, 2023 rule announcement. A firm that cannot line up its statements with that clock from the first day is the wrong firm for a breach.
Last updated: November 5, 2026.
On this page
- What are the eight questions to ask a crisis PR firm?
- What should a crisis PR firm do in the first 24 hours?
- How should a crisis PR firm work with your lawyers?
- How do you test a firm with a scenario?
- How do you check references?
- How do you compare proposals side by side?
- What should the engagement terms include?
- What red flags should you watch for?
- What should you do next?
- Frequently asked questions
What are the eight questions to ask a crisis PR firm?
The eight questions below separate firms that have run real incidents from firms that describe them. Ask each one of every firm on your shortlist, and compare the answers side by side.
| Question | Why it matters | What a good answer sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Have you handled a crisis like mine? | Breaches, recalls, executive conduct and activist campaigns run on different clocks | Names the type of case, what the firm did and what happened next, without breaking client confidences |
| Who will answer the phone at 2 a.m.? | Crises do not wait for business hours | Names specific senior people, with a backup for each, and a written escalation path |
| How fast can you start? | The first hours set the story | Gives an hour count, and explains what happens in the first 60 minutes |
| How will you work with our lawyers? | Statements carry legal exposure | Describes a joint review step with a time limit, not a veto in either direction |
| What conflicts do you hold? | A conflicted firm cannot advise freely | Discloses current and recent clients in your industry before you ask twice |
| How are you paid? | Retainer, project and hourly fees behave differently under pressure | Puts the scope, the rates and the expense policy in writing before work starts |
| Which clients can I call? | References show how the firm behaves when things go wrong | Offers two clients with comparable incidents and lets you ask what went wrong |
| How do you measure results? | Press volume is not the same as a recovered reputation | Names measures such as sentiment, search results and how AI engines describe the brand months later |
What should a crisis PR firm do in the first 24 hours?
In the first 24 hours a crisis PR firm should establish the facts, set up one approval path, issue a first holding statement and start monitoring coverage and search. The list below is a working sequence for judging a firm's answer to "how fast can you start". The timing is my recommendation and will vary with the type of incident.
- Hour 0 to 1: Gather the facts that are confirmed, the facts that are not and the people who can speak to each. Name one decision-maker and one spokesperson.
- Hour 1 to 3: Draft a holding statement that says what happened, who is affected, what the company is doing and when the next update will come. Send it to counsel for review within the agreed time limit.
- Hour 3 to 8: Brief employees, customers or partners who should hear the news from the company first. Prepare answers to the five questions reporters are most likely to ask.
- Hour 8 to 24: Monitor coverage, social posts and search results. Correct factual errors with sources. Publish an update at the time promised.
- End of day one: Review what was said, what was learned and what the next 72 hours require.
A firm that describes a sequence like this, without being prompted, has run incidents before. A firm that talks only about relationships with reporters has told you what it sells.
How should a crisis PR firm work with your lawyers?
A crisis PR firm should work with your lawyers through a joint review step with a time limit, so statements are accurate and legally reviewed without being delayed past usefulness. The standard to ask for is that counsel reviews every outbound statement, and communications decides the wording within the limits counsel sets. Your crisis communication plan should set that approval path in writing, including the maximum review time.
For a public company, ask the firm how it keeps a press statement consistent with a regulatory filing. A breach statement and an 8-K both need to carry the same four fields: nature, scope, timing and impact.
How do you test a firm with a scenario?
Test each shortlisted firm by giving it the same realistic scenario and asking for a first holding statement within an hour. Compare the drafts against the same checklist: does the statement name what happened, who is affected, the company action, the speaker and the next update time.
If the scenario involves wrongdoing, ask for the apology language too, and score it with the five parts in the corporate apology guide. A firm that drafts a defense inside the apology has told you how it will advise you under pressure. Also ask what the firm will offer when facts are still unconfirmed.
How do you check references?
Check references by calling clients who faced a crisis similar to yours and asking what the firm did in the first 24 hours, what it got wrong, and how it handled disagreement with the client's lawyers. Ask each reference whether they would hire the firm again for the same type of incident.
Ask the firm for public work as well. The crisis case study library shows the kind of analysis you should expect from any firm that claims crisis experience: named events, the response and the lesson.
How do you compare proposals side by side?
Compare proposals with a simple scorecard that rates each firm on the same criteria, so a persuasive presentation does not outweigh a weaker answer. Score each row from one to five after the meeting, not during it. The criteria and the weights below are a starting point, and you should change the weights to match your risk.
| Criterion | Suggested weight | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant experience | 25 percent | Comparable incidents, named and described, with outcomes |
| Senior availability | 20 percent | Named people, backups and a written escalation path |
| Speed of start | 15 percent | A clear first-hour plan and a stated response time |
| Legal coordination | 15 percent | A joint review step with a time limit |
| Conflicts and independence | 10 percent | Full disclosure of current and recent clients |
| Fees and terms | 10 percent | Scope, rates and expenses in writing |
| References and public work | 5 percent | Two comparable clients and published analysis |
Add up the weighted scores, then discuss any firm that scores well overall but low on senior availability or legal coordination. Those two gaps hurt most when an incident starts.
What should the engagement terms include?
The engagement terms should state the scope of work, the named team, the response time, the fee structure, the expense policy and how either side can end the arrangement. Put these in writing before an incident, and have counsel review them. A retainer signed in advance is usually faster to activate than a proposal negotiated during an emergency.
- Scope: The types of incident covered and what is excluded, such as litigation support or investor relations.
- Team: The named senior contacts and the backup for each.
- Response time: The number of hours within which the firm starts work after a call.
- Fees and expenses: The retainer or hourly rates, plus how third-party costs such as monitoring or media buying are approved.
- Confidentiality: How the firm protects privileged material and who may see it.
- Ending the engagement: Notice terms and what happens to materials and contacts on exit.
What red flags should you watch for?
Five red flags should end a conversation with a firm or at least slow it down.
- It promises a specific outcome, such as a story killed or a reputation restored by a date.
- It cannot name the senior people who would work your account.
- It will not disclose conflicts.
- It recommends denial or a defense before the facts are confirmed.
- It treats legal coordination as an obstacle, not a step.
What should you do next?
Shortlist three firms, ask all eight questions, run the same scenario test with each, and sign the retainer before you need it. Then store the firm's contacts in your crisis communication plan, with a backup for every name, and drill the relationship once a quarter.
For more on this topic, see the crisis PR overview, my guide to reputation management and the executive communications guide. 5W's crisis PR practice handles these situations.
Ronn Torossian is the founder and chairman of 5W, a PR, creative and AI Visibility agency. He is the publisher of Everything-PR and the author of two best-selling editions of For Immediate Release.
Related Pillars
Frequently asked questions
How do you choose a crisis PR firm?
Ask eight questions about experience with your type of crisis, senior availability, speed of start, legal coordination, conflicts, fees, references and how results are measured. Ask them before an incident, and compare every firm on the same scenario test.
When should you hire a crisis PR firm?
Before a crisis happens. A retainer signed in advance lets the firm start in hours, while a firm chosen mid-crisis is chosen under pressure and with less time to check conflicts and references.
How should a crisis PR firm work with lawyers?
Through a joint review step with a time limit. Counsel reviews every outbound statement, and communications decides the wording within the limits counsel sets.
What are red flags when hiring a crisis PR firm?
Promising a specific outcome, not naming the senior people on the account, refusing to disclose conflicts, recommending denial before the facts are confirmed and treating legal coordination as an obstacle.
How do you test a crisis PR firm before hiring it?
Give each shortlisted firm the same realistic scenario and ask for a first holding statement within an hour. Score each draft against the same checklist: what happened, who is affected, the company action, the speaker and the next update time.
What should a crisis PR retainer cover?
The types of incident covered, the named senior team, the response time, the fee structure and expense policy, confidentiality and the terms for ending the engagement.
