The strongest corporate apology examples name the harm, own it, state a dated fix, use a speaker with authority and set a follow-up date. Eight public apologies from 2016 to 2026 are scored here on those five parts: Wells Fargo, Bud Light, Cracker Barrel, Target, Good Good and Callaway, Mbappe, Sanrio and Skims. Each entry shows the strongest part, the weakest part and what happened next.
Updated November 19, 2026. Scores are editorial judgment based on the reporting cited for each case. Where the reporting does not quote a statement, the entry says so and does not guess.
What are the five parts of a corporate apology?
A corporate apology has five parts: the named harm, the ownership statement, the fix, the speaker and the follow-up date. The corporate apology guide explains each part and gives a test question for it. This page applies the same five parts to eight public apologies so a team can see how each one held up.
For the wording of a first message, see what to say in a crisis statement. For the full list of dated cases, see the PR crisis examples page.
How do the eight apologies score at a glance?
The table lists each case with the part that worked best, the part that worked worst and the reaction that followed. Dates and figures come from the reporting named in each section below.
| Case | Date | Strongest part | Weakest part | What happened next |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wells Fargo | September 2016 | Fix and speaker | Ownership | Lawmakers kept pressing the CEO |
| Bud Light | April 2023 | Speaker | Named harm | Sales down nearly 30% by May |
| Cracker Barrel | August 2025 | Fix | Ownership | Logo reversed within eight days |
| Target | August 2026 | Fix | Named harm (wording not quoted) | Apology rejected in public |
| Good Good and Callaway | 2026 | Callaway's ownership | Good Good's ownership | Two Good Good leaders left |
| Kylian Mbappe | October 2026 | Speaker | Fix | Sponsors acted before the apology |
| Sanrio | October 2026 | Fix | Named harm | Collaboration canceled |
| Skims | November 2026 | Fix | Ownership | Refund kept it a pricing story |
What did the older apologies show about ownership and speaker?
The two older cases show that a speaker with authority cannot rescue a statement that defends the company. Both are drawn from reporting at the time.
Wells Fargo (September 2016). The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau fined the bank $100 million in September 2016 over accounts that may not have been authorized. CEO John Stumpf told the House Financial Services Committee on September 29 that he was "deeply sorry," and in the same appearance said no executives above the branch manager level appeared to be aware of the misconduct, according to the Associated Press. The strongest parts were the fix and the speaker: the board stripped Stumpf of $41 million in stock awards and former retail banking head Carrie Tolstedt of $19 million, and the bank pointed to $2.6 million in refunds and the accelerated end of sales goals. The weakest part was ownership, because the defense invited questions about what leaders knew and when.
Bud Light (April 2023). Anheuser-Busch CEO Brendan Whitworth said on April 14 that the company never intended to be part of a discussion that divides people. According to Fox Business, the statement did not mention influencer Dylan Mulvaney or the boycott. The strongest part was the speaker, since the CEO himself spoke. The weakest was the named harm: a statement written for every audience named none of them. Fox News reported that by May sales were down nearly 30% and Anheuser-Busch had lost $27 billion in market value.
What did the 2025 apology show about a fix?
The 2025 case shows that a dated fix can end a story, and that a defense before the fix costs credibility.
Cracker Barrel (August 2025). The chain unveiled a new logo on August 18, 2025 and defended it. On August 25 it said it could have done a better job sharing who it is, and on August 26 it announced the new logo was going away and the "Old Timer" would remain, according to ABC News. WHIO reported that shares fell more than 10% in the days after the unveiling. The strongest part was the fix, because it was specific and carried a date. The weakest was ownership: the first response defended the change, so the later reversal read as pressure, not conviction.
What did the 2026 apologies show?
The five 2026 cases show how many ways an apology can fail even when the company acts quickly. Each fact is attributed to the reporting that carries it.
Target (August 2026). Target pulled a children's Halloween costume and apologized after social media users said it resembled blackface and minstrel caricatures, according to a Global Banking and Finance Review factbox, which reported that shares fell about 5% on August 25. Axios reported on September 3 that actress Viola Davis publicly rejected the apology. The strongest part was the fix, since the costume was pulled. The cited reporting does not quote the apology, so the named-harm part cannot be scored from it, and the public rejection shows it did not satisfy critics.
Good Good and Callaway (2026). An ad drew backlash, and Good Good CEO Matt Kendrick apologized, according to Axios. After Callaway cut ties, Kendrick accused Callaway of letting Good Good take the fall, and by September 3 both Kendrick and Good Good president Joe Flannery had left. PRovoke Media reported that Callaway CEO Chip Brewer acknowledged the company had approved the content and said that approval should never have happened. Callaway's ownership was the strongest part of the case. Good Good's was the weakest, because blaming a partner extends the story.
Kylian Mbappe (October 2026). After a video of his comment about Mao Zedong circulated on October 26, Dongpeng ended its contract and at least two other Chinese brands dropped him, according to Al Jazeera. On October 27 he published an apology in French, Mandarin and English saying his comment was ill-judged and that he understood it hurt many people. The speaker was the strongest part, and the choice of languages matched the audience that was hurt. The weakest was the fix: the reporting we cite names no action or follow-up date.
Sanrio (October 2026). Sanrio apologized on October 29 over a merchandise tie-up with the Japanese spy drama Vivant and canceled the collaboration, according to AFP. The fix was the strongest part, because the cancellation was concrete. The weakest was the named harm: the reporting we cite describes an apology over the tie-up and does not quote what the harm was said to be.
Skims (November 2026). Skims told outlets on November 8 that it was aware of the feedback on its $148 advent calendar, and Inc reported that buyers could return it for a full refund or keep it and take $150 in store credit. FashionUnited reported that one creator's video had passed 18.9 million views by November 9. The fix was the strongest part. The weakest was ownership, since "aware of the feedback" is not an apology. This is a remedy more than an apology, and it kept the story to a pricing complaint. The Skims response analysis has the full breakdown.
What patterns repeat across the eight apologies?
Three patterns repeat, and they are editorial observations drawn from the eight cases.
- The fix is the part most companies get right. Five of the eight cases have a clear action, such as a costume pulled, a canceled collaboration, a reversed logo or a refund. A fix carries weight because a reporter can check it.
- Ownership and named harm are the parts most often missing. Defensive wording, as in Wells Fargo and Cracker Barrel, and generic wording, as in Bud Light and Skims, left the audience's own grievance unaddressed.
- Almost no apology sets a follow-up date. None of the reporting we cite for these eight cases describes a dated update, which is the part that lets an audience check the promise.
For apologies scored one at a time as they happen, see the Apology Autopsy posts on the Stephen A. Smith apology, OpenAI's Australia apology and the Yang Min-hyeok apology.
How do you score your own apology before it goes out?
Score a draft apology by giving each of the five parts a yes, partly or no before it is released. Read it aloud to someone who was affected and answer five questions.
- Does the first sentence name the harm and the people harmed?
- Is every "if," "but" and "however" gone?
- Does the fix have an action, a number and a date?
- Can the speaker approve the fix?
- Does the last sentence name when and where the next update will appear?
The first 24 hours of a reputation crisis covers the timing, and the crisis communications case study library holds more named cases.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a good corporate apology?
A good corporate apology names the specific harm, accepts responsibility without conditions, states a dated fix, comes from a speaker with authority and sets a follow-up date. The corporate apology guide tests each part.
What are examples of corporate apologies that failed?
Wells Fargo's 2016 apology pressed on after the CEO defended the bank in the same appearance, according to the Associated Press. Bud Light's 2023 statement did not mention the influencer or the boycott, according to Fox Business, and sales were down nearly 30% by May.
Which companies apologized quickly in 2026?
Target pulled a costume and apologized in August 2026, Sanrio canceled a tie-up on October 29 and Skims offered a refund in November. Speed helped each story stay narrower, but Target's apology was still rejected in public, according to Axios.
Should a company apologize in more than one language?
When the harmed audience speaks another language, yes. Kylian Mbappe published his October 27, 2026 apology in French, Mandarin and English, according to the reporting we cite.
Is a refund an apology?
No. A refund is a fix, which is one of the five parts. Skims' November 2026 refund offer kept the story narrow, but the reporting we cite does not describe an apology.
Should a company blame a partner in a public apology?
No. Good Good's CEO accused Callaway of letting the company take the fall, and the story ran on, according to Axios. Settle who approved what in private, and say what each side will change.
How soon after a crisis should an apology go out?
Soon enough to name facts the company has verified, and not before. Mbappe's apology came a day after his comment circulated, and Cracker Barrel's reversal came eight days after its logo launch, according to the reporting we cite.
